RSS

Product Review: Soap Nuts

November 21, 2011

Product Reviews

Using soap nuts instead of detergent

I can hear what you are thinking-  “Okay, I can go along with making tea from mint I’ve grown or using the persimmons I find to make jam, but real soap does not come from nuts!”

I was very skeptical too.  I held off trying these for several reasons (in large part because I’m annoyed by big shipping charges and I haven’t found a local source), but I finally ordered some a couple weeks ago.  I thought you may be interested in my experience.

A Little Background

Soap nuts (or berries) come from the Sapindus plants which are large shrubs or small trees.  They have been used for thousands of years by Asians and Native Americans to produce soap because they contain a natural surfactant called saponin.  The plants are native to temperate and tropical regions.

To prepare them for use as a detergent alternative, the nuts/berries are sun-dried and de-seeded.  They are available from several sources, including Lehman’s.   The best price I found was for “pieces” from Naturoli by way of Amazon.  Pieces only come in the 5 lb size, so if you want to try them out, you may want a trial size first.

Why I Wanted to Try Them

My primary interest was for laundry, though they can be used for other things.   With as many people as there are in our family and all the hard dirty work and play we do, we create a lot of laundry.  I need to do at least 3 loads a day to keep up (I don’t do laundry on Sunday).  That’s a lot of detergent.

I’ve tried various laundry soaps over the years.  I’ve always intended to begin mixing up my own from washing soda, Borax, etc.  (which I hear good things about), but I just have never gotten around to it.  I know that is an economical and effective way to produce a lot of detergent.  Somehow, it has just been one of the things that I just haven’t made time for with all the many things that need my attention.

Most of our married life, I have bought some generic bucket of powdered stuff from a big box store.  It was pretty cheap and then we had the bucket for various chores etc. when it was empty.  In recent years, I’ve been thinking more about the effects on our ground water (by way of the septic tank) of all those phosphates in traditional detergents.  At present, we have “city water,” but someday we may want to dig a well.  In addition, our house is on the highest point of the rolling property and it may be possible that the run-off heads down to our ponds which the animals use for drinking.  Seems better to just use something more eco-friendly.

Seeing that Lehman’s had them for sale gave me more confidence than I otherwise would have had since I know they are a reputable company and they sell a lot o things that line up well with preparedness.

The last main reason I was interested in giving soap nuts a try was because they sounded like they would be very economical.

My Experience

My 5 lb “pieces” box came with 1 muslin bag in which to put the nuts during washing.  (I read the Amazon online reviews and followed the advice there to order a couple additional bags, which were not expensive).  The instructions said to use the equivalent of 5 nuts for average loads and that they could be re-used for 4-7 washings.  Wow!  This means that a 5 lb box should wash at least 800 loads of laundry!

Hanging clothes out to dryI was eager to try them out and didn’t have to wait since there is always dirty laundry.  I did 5 consecutive load with that same set of soap nuts.  I used warm water since the reviews on Amazon said they performed better in warm.  The clothes came out clean and fragrance-free.

I should mention that some of what I washed that first day was wet bedding from a child’s overnight accident.  It can be hard to get that odor out (and sometimes it’s not evident until after drying), but when I took the sheets and such out of the dryer, they had no unpleasant scent.  That was nice!

I managed to catch the laundry cycle between wash and rinse the first many times and fished out the bag of nuts, thinking that they really needed to be removed even though the instructions didn’t specify that.  To me, it seemed they would be adding “detergent” back to the rinse water.  I also didn’t want to “use up” the nuts prematurely.  It was a bit difficult to locate that little bag in all the wet clothes, but I eventually found it every time.

In the last couple of loads, I missed the interval after the first spin before the rinse water fills and the nuts stayed in.  I couldn’t feel any difference in the clothes and I’m thinking that the saponins are not released much in the cold rinse water.  The instructions say that they should work fine in cold, but will perform better if soaked in hot water and then that all added to the wash.

After the fifth load, I dutifully removed the nuts from the bag.  They were very soft, but they still had a couple bubbles clinging to them.  Hmmm…. guess they could be used at least one more time.

Once they seemed “spent,” I put them in the compost and refilled the bag.  I think I’m sold.

How These Are Different Than Your Regular Detergent

It’s worth mentioning that these are not ” heavy duty” cleaners.  You will still need to pre-treat spots and if you are a stickler for super-bright whites, you will still have to use a oxygen booster or whatever you use now.  Soapnuts are just a good alternative to other regular detergents.

Since these are a natural product, most people with sensitive skin seem to do well with them (from reviews I read) and they are reported to be excellent for cloth diapers, especially because they leave no residue that prevent absorption (like a fabric softener).  I cannot comment on that use because I have not tried them for diapers yet, but as noted above, they worked well for removing ammonia smells from urine.

doing laundryIt is important not to overload the washer because good water flow is essential.  I have always started the water, added my detergent, and let it mostly fill before adding clothes so I know the detergent is well dissolved and distributed.  It also makes it less likely I will overstuff the washer.

These soap nuts do not contain the phosphates and other sudsy agents that you are used to.  Do not expect to see a washer full of foamy bubbles.  I didn’t even think the wash water felt very soapy after a few minutes agitation, so I was skeptical.  They seem to work though, and I’m happy with them.

One of the best parts is the cost.  If I’ve calculated correctly, using soap nuts in the place of regular detergent costs about $.06 per load (about 7 1/2 cents if I include the cost of shipping).  A quick comparison with Tide shows that to be $.25 per load, if my math is right.

And here is another thing that appeals to me- a 5 lb bag  doesn’t take up much space.  I would have to buy more than 6 large heavy boxes of  detergent to wash that many loads of laundry and be concerned it is stored somewhere it can’t get humid or damp.  I could store a few 5 lb bags of these in the root cellar we hope to begin soon and be set for ages.

If that tell-tale “clean” scent from name brand detergents is important to you, than you probably will not be happy with soap nuts.  I don’t smell anything on our laundry, but that is fine with me.  I decided a long time ago that I could do without the perfume to save money.  Or, you could use a fabric softener to add the scent in the dryer.  A lot of people who use these nuts seem to use a bit of white vinegar in the final rinse (if they have hard water) or nothing at all and find the clothes fresh and fluffy after machine drying.

Other Perks

According to some research and the instructions card that came with my order, these nuts can be used to create cleaners for other purposes-  most notably, to make hair and skin products for people with eczema and other sensitive skin issues.  It has some pest-deterrent characteristics so it is good for using on clothes to ward off insects.  One source said it came be used to remove lice.  That could be handy in a less than perfect world!

If you’ve ever used soap nuts, what brand did you use and what have been your experiences?  Please share them in the comment section.

Related Posts

14 Comments on “Product Review: Soap Nuts”

  1. Kate Says:

    Yay for soap nuts! I was skeptical too till I tried them. http://cleanerplanet.com has shipping prices built in on their store page… Not sure where you are but they ship to Canada and the US. Their selection isn’t as big as Naturoli, but thought I’d mention it anyhow :) they sell the pieces in 250g (1/2lb) bags.

    Reply

    • Laura Says:

      Thanks for mentioning another site. We aren’t getting paid for any of our recommendations and it’s always good to shop around.

      I appreciate the web address- I’ll check them out. Thanks for the comment.

      Reply

    • Brenda J. Elliott Says:

      That url should be cleanerplanet.ca

      I just started using the soap nuts, too. Have to wait to see how they work out before commenting.

      Reply

  2. Laura Says:

    I also forgot to mention in the post that, from what I read, soap nuts work in HE machines too b/c of the low sudsing nature of them. We don’t own an HE machine (just a plain old non-electronic one), so I can’t comment on how well they work or compare them to other HE detergents.

    Reply

  3. millenniumfly Says:

    We’ve used something similar for a year or so now and have found the reusable laundry option a worthwhile investment. Thanks for pointing out yet another option.

    Reply

  4. Mary Says:

    I just tried these and I love them. I appreciate all of the user tips. I bought them from Nutty Mother. This is a great product even on my two athletic teenagers clothes.

    Reply

  5. michael Says:

    please folks, do not be fooled by this article. i had been ‘mixing’ my own detergent, but heard about soap nuts and decided to give a try. it’s not that clothes come out without that ‘clean’ smell: they come out smelling like wet dog. and clothes, even lightly soiled, do NOT come out clean. this kind of product preys on folks trying to be eco-minded – really pisses me off.

    Reply

    • Laura Says:

      Michael,

      I’m sorry you did not find success with soapnuts, but as you can see, others of us have. I have no financial stake in these- I was simply giving a review of our experiences with them and providing other information I found on the subject. Your insinuation that I was trying to “fool” people is untrue and ugly. You are welcome to offer your alternative opinions and experiences, but we ask that you keep the tone polite and respectful.

      As I mentioned above, I do not consider them “heavy-duty cleaners,” but I find them useful for the everyday stuff. An extra soak for more soiled stuff helps them come cleaner too. It is essential to spot treat any stains (also stated above).

      I have noticed no odor at all left behind by the soapnuts. Possibly you have mildew in the outer tub of your washing machine that is leaving that smell. Other “detergents” may be leaving enough scent on your clothes that you don’t notice it when using other kinds. Running an empty load with just vinegar or bleach may get rid of that odor. I have also seen products advertised on TV for that problem.

      On a separate note- I was just thinking this morning that I needed to revisit this topic and add my one real frustration with using them is finding that little cloth bag when I am taking the clothes out of the washer. That can be aggravating. It often gets into the sleeve or a shirt or something and I have to shake each piece of clothing as I take them out to find it, sometimes more than once.

      Michael, if you have a homemade detergent recipe you’d like to share here, we’d be glad to see and try it also.

      Reply

    • Mrs. Jilly Fisher Says:

      My first impression was that they do smell like wet dog. So I have to agree with Michael. I received a sample to try and I am nervous to use it. Do the clothes come out smelling like wet dog or the nuts just smell like that?

      Reply

  6. jean Says:

    I think the “sharks” missed out on a great deal especially because they are inexpensive to buy and aIl hate lugging all those bottles (that end up in landfills)…I will continue to buy this product and try to spread the word the best I can..the “sharks” are not always right..in fact I think they miss the boat on a lot of things

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Cloth Diapers, part 2 | PreppingToSurvive.com - January 12, 2012

    [...] to use, again there is debate.  Borax is easy to find, pretty inexpensive, and does a good job.  Soap nuts get high ratings too (and remember, soap nuts are very space economical!).  Some of the most [...]

  2. In our market….. | Valerie's Market of Jupiter Florida - November 3, 2012

    [...] to tell you about a few unique items that you may find interesting in our market. We have ‘Soap Nuts‘ laundry detergent, Miracle Noodles, Dr. Larry’s Tranquility, XyloBurst sugarless gum, [...]

  3. Imperfect is the New Perfect #2: Born Perfect? « sacraparental - November 18, 2012

    [...] what I mean. For one thing, I got into using soapnuts for laundry while I was pregnant. They’re awesome for reasons of thrift and environmental impact, but the [...]

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,954 other followers

%d bloggers like this: